Search This Blog

Thursday, November 7, 2019

Moses Did Not Write the "Five Books of Moses"


As listed by renowned Bible scholar, 
Richard Elliott Friedman, in his book
The Bible With Sources Revealed, HarperOne, New York, NY, 2003
the actual writers of the “Five Books of Moses” were:

J“For two centuries (from 922 to 722 BCE) the biblical promised-land was divided into two kingdoms: the kingdom of Israel in the north and the kingdom of Judah in the south. A text known as J was composed during this period. It is called J because, from its very first sentence, it refers to God by the proper name of YHWH (“Jahwe” in German, which was the language of many of the founding works in this field).  J was composed by an author living in the southern kingdom of Judah.”
(Friedman, p 3).

E“A second text, know as E, was composed during this same period.” (from 922 to 722 BCE) “E was composed by a priest living in the northern kingdom of Israel. It is called E because it refers to the deity simply as God, which in the original Hebrew is Elohim, or by the divine name El in its stories until the time of Moses.” “…the E text developed the idea that the proper name of God, YHWH, was not known on earth until God chose to reveal it to Moses.” (Friedman,  p. 4).

RJE “In the year 722 BCE, the Assyrian empire destroyed the northern kingdom of Israel. J and E were then no longer separated by a border. These two versions of the people’s history now existed side by side in the kingdom of Judah. In the years that followed, someone assembled a history that used both J and E as sources. The editor/historian who combine J and E into a single work is known as the Redactor of JE or RJE, for short.” (Friedman, p. 4)

P“The third main source is known as P because one of its central concerns is the priesthood.”   It is most likely  “…that P was composed not long after J and E were combined—specifically, that it was produced by the Jerusalem priesthood as an alternative to the history told in JE. (Friedman, p. 4)

Dtn“The final main source is known as D because it takes up most of the book of Deuteronomy. More specifically, Deuteronomy comprises: (1) a law code that takes up chapters 12-26 known as Dtn. (Friedman, p. 5)

Dtr1 The original, Josianic edition of the Deuteronomistic history is called,  Dtr1. (Friedman, p. 5)

Dtr2 The second, exilic edition of the Deuteronomistic history is called Dtr2. (Friedman, p. 5)

R – All original sources and modifying editions were put together by an editor into the final five-book work. This final editor is known as the Redactor, or for short: R. (Friedman, p. 5)

Other – e.g. Other independent texts, e.g. Book of records used by R (Friedman, p. 32)

No comments:

Post a Comment